
New Arrivals — Browse our catalog for the latest authentic Japanese sword arrivals. Browse →
Eiroku 3 to Genki 1 (1560–1570), a series of repeated confrontations
Karasawayama Castle, Aso District, Shimotsuke Province (present-day Fuji-chō and Tochimoto-chō, Sano City, Tochigi Prefecture)
Forces
Uesugi Forces
Sano Forces (Karasawayama garrison) and allied Hōjō forces
About 13 min read
Karasawayama Castle, in Shimotsuke Province (present-day Sano, Tochigi Prefecture), is counted among the "Seven Famous Castles of Kantō" and is a fortress of formidable strength. From the Eiroku era through the Genki era, Uesugi Kenshin launched ten assaults against this castle, yet he never held it for long. It is the story of a decade-long contest that unfolded as the Uesugi and Later Hōjō clan vied for supremacy in Kantō, shaped by the flexible diplomacy of Sano Masatsuna and the solidity of Karasawayama Castle.
Uesugi Kenshin came from the Nagao family, which served as deputy governor (shugodai) of Echigo. When Kantō kanrei Uesugi Norimasa was defeated by the Later Hōjō clan and fled to Echigo, Kenshin inherited his name and the office of Kantō kanrei. The Kantō kanrei was originally the authoritative post that governed Kantō in place of the Muromachi shogunate, and by succeeding to it Kenshin gained a legitimate cause before the Kantō lords. From then on, Kenshin declared that he would restore order to Kantō. From Eiroku 3 (1560) into the following year, he carried out a large-scale expedition to Kantō, gathering the Kantō lords and advancing to besiege Odawara Castle, the main base of the Later Hōjō clan. Within this series of campaigns, Karasawayama Castle lay at the eastern edge of Kenshin's sphere of influence and on the border with the spheres of the pro-Uesugi lords of northern Kantō, including the Satake clan. It was therefore a key point that Kenshin attacked again and again. Bringing the castle under his control meant more than gaining a single fortress. It also carried considerable political significance in displaying Uesugi power to the Kantō country lords.
The Sano clan, a noble house of Shimotsuke Province, is said to trace its descent from Fujiwara no Hidesato (Tawara Tōta), and it had long made Karasawayama Castle its base. Hidesato is renowned as the general who suppressed the Taira no Masakado Rebellion in the mid-Heian period, and his military reputation became a spiritual pillar of the Shimotsuke warrior bands. When the Sengoku period began, the Sano domains came to be squeezed between two great powers: the Uesugi of Echigo (first Kantō kanrei Uesugi Norimasa, and later Uesugi Kenshin, who inherited his name and office) and the Later Hōjō clan, which was expanding from Sagami into Kantō. The head of the clan, Sano Masatsuna, pursued a pragmatic diplomatic line, sometimes siding with the Uesugi and sometimes with the Hōjō, in a situation where the clan's survival would be in doubt unless it submitted to one of the two powers. The Sano lands lay at the southern tip of Shimotsuke Province and commanded a road that led deep into the Kantō Plain, so they were a strategic position that neither power could afford to ignore.
The rivalry between Uesugi Kenshin and Karasawayama Castle began in the 2nd month of Eiroku 3 (1560) (some theories date it to Eiroku 2). In that year, Hōjō Ujimasa attacked the castle with an army of more than 30,000. Masatsuna asked Kenshin for help, and Kenshin is said to have repulsed the Hōjō army with a small force, although the historicity of this battle has been questioned. From then on, Kenshin regarded the fate of Karasawayama Castle as important on each of his Kantō campaigns, and whenever the Sano clan turned to the Hōjō side, he dispatched his forces and tried to capture it. That same year, Kenshin began his first full-scale expedition to Kantō, which would lead to the siege of Odawara Castle, and Karasawayama Castle was positioned as one of the important footholds for that campaign.
For roughly ten years, from Eiroku 3 (1560) to Genki 1 (1570), Kenshin advanced his army against Karasawayama Castle many times. Yet whenever Kenshin's large army approached, Sano Masatsuna quickly surrendered and swore allegiance, and once Kenshin withdrew to Echigo, he turned back to the Hōjō side. This conduct is said to have greatly irritated Kenshin, but it was also a highly realistic strategy by which a small clan could survive between two great daimyo. Masatsuna was born in Kyōroku 2 (1529) and Kenshin in Kyōroku 3 (1530), so the two were nearly of the same generation. The picture of two commanders of similar age carrying on an evenly matched game of maneuver for nearly ten years, in an asymmetrical power relationship between a great state and a small clan, has continued to draw the interest of later historians and storytellers. During this period, Karasawayama Castle repeatedly shifted between the Uesugi side and the Later Hōjō side, and it remained a mirror reflecting changes in the balance of the two powers' spheres in Kantō.
The greatest reason Karasawayama Castle could withstand Kenshin's attacks for nearly ten years lay in the steepness of its terrain, built on Mt. Karasawa at 247 meters above sea level. Surrounded by steep cliffs, with a complex arrangement of baileys that strengthened the castle's defenses, it was known as "the finest mountain castle in Kantō." The castle's sturdiness made it extremely difficult for Kenshin's army, which had marched a long way from Echigo into Kantō, to capture it while stretching its supply lines. Heavy winter snow and the vast expanse of the Kantō Plain also made it hard for the Echigo forces to stay in the field for a long time. The layout of Karasawayama Castle, with its many baileys arranged in tiers across the rugged mountain mass, allowed even a small garrison to hold out for a long time against a large army, and this was the greatest weapon that quietly supported the survival of the Sano clan.
Uesugi Kenshin is known for his deep devotion to Bishamonten. Among the famous swords handed down to the present day as Kenshin's own blades is the tantō "Kenshin Kagemitsu" (a National Treasure), the work of the smith Kagemitsu of the Bizen Osafune school.
In Tenshō 2 (1574), Sano Masatsuna died. Masatsuna's heir, Sano Munetsuna, was likewise placed in a difficult position between the Uesugi and the Later Hōjō clan. After Munetsuna's death, Hōjō Ujitada, who came from the Later Hōjō clan, was adopted into the Sano family, and the Sano clan continued to maintain a complex relationship with both powers while keeping its house name. In Tenshō 18 (1590), the Later Hōjō clan was destroyed in the Odawara campaign. Ujitada, who had entered from the Hōjō clan, was expelled, and Sano Fusatsuna, Masatsuna's younger brother, who had been serving Toyotomi Hideyoshi, took over Karasawayama Castle. Afterward, Sano Nobuyoshi, an adopted heir, sided with the Eastern Army at the Battle of Sekigahara and had his domains confirmed. However, in Keichō 7 (1602), Sano Castle was built at the foot of the mountain and Karasawayama Castle was abandoned. In Keichō 19 (1614), Nobuyoshi was dispossessed, and the Sano family as a daimyo house came to an end. Today, the ruins of Karasawayama Castle have been designated among the "Continued Top 100 Japanese Castles," and many history enthusiasts visit it as one of the finest mountain castles in Kantō.