New Arrivals — Browse our catalog for the latest authentic Japanese sword arrivals. Browse →
* Image is for illustrative purposes only.For samurai of the Edo period, membership in a domain was the very foundation of their status. Their rank and privileges as samurai were guaranteed by receiving a stipend and serving a domain lord, and leaving one's domain register was not merely a change of employment but an act tantamount to surrendering the very foundation of one's status. The act of leaving one's domain without permission was called "shuppon" or "kakeochi," and was subject to severe punishment in many domains, with some taking the stance that harsh penalties were not to be spared. Even so, during the Bakumatsu period, samurai who defected from their domains in order to devote themselves to national affairs, or because they could no longer tolerate the divergence between their domain's views and their own convictions, appeared one after another throughout the country.
From the domain's perspective, a samurai who had defected was a subject for punishment and officially lost their status as a domain samurai. However, sword-wearing itself was a custom tied not to domain registration but to the samurai social class, so defectors were not immediately deprived of their swords. This was because sashiryō (the sword one habitually carried at one's side) was in most cases not a tool lent by the domain but personal property, and it was common for it to remain in the defector's possession after leaving the domain.
In other words, sword-wearing by domain-defecting rōshi had a dual character: "a sword-wearing that continued as a right, yet was an unstable sword-wearing that had lost its backing." Since the Sengoku period, it had not been unusual for rōnin who had left their masters to wander from place to place while retaining their weapons, and the domain-defecting rōshi of the Edo period can be understood as existing along this same continuum. What was different was that domain defection after the governance of the Edo shogunate had stabilized carried political meaning beyond mere "desertion," and defectors more easily became subjects of surveillance by the shogunate and various domains.
The most widely known representative example of a domain-defecting rōshi is Sakamoto Ryōma, who defected from the Tosa domain. Having left Tosa in Bunkyū 2 (1862), Ryōma thereafter acted as a rōshi belonging to no particular domain, studying under Katsu Kaishū while building his own network of connections, and carried out activities that would lead to his later mediation of the Satchō Alliance and the founding of the Kaientai. It is said that his position of not being bound to any single domain — a result of defection — also enabled him to act as a negotiator transcending domain boundaries. It should be noted, however, that this was a freedom obtained in exchange for the instability of status that defection entailed. Nakaoka Shintarō, who likewise defected from the Tosa domain, is also known as a patriot who rushed between the Satsuma and Chōshū domains and devoted himself to bringing about the alliance. What the two had in common was that, even after losing the backing of their domain, they maintained their dignity as sword-bearing samurai while forging a stage for activity that transcended domain boundaries.
In Bakumatsu Kyoto, domain-defecting rōshi who had gathered from across the country served as the driving force behind political movements, while at the same time being viewed with wariness by both the shogunate and various domains as elements that disturbed public order. Just as the rōshi group assembled under the pretext of guarding the shogun's journey to Kyoto later became the nucleus of the Shinsengumi, the shogunate's side was compelled to respond on two fronts: suppressing rōshi on one hand, and organizing and utilizing them on the other. The streets of Kyoto, through which sword-bearing rōshi came and went, can be said to have existed in a state of constant tension, with sword-wearing as proof of status side by side with enforcement for the maintenance of public order. Even for those charged with patrolling the city streets, it was not easy to distinguish by appearance alone whether the sword-bearing individual before them was a regular domain samurai or a defected rōshi. As a result, the situation in which samurai of different positions — sharing the same outward form of sword-wearing — passed each other on the same streets can be said to have further heightened the tension that pervaded Bakumatsu Kyoto.
Domain defection was a weighty decision to voluntarily relinquish one's domain registration, the very foundation of one's status as a samurai, and was subject to severe punishment in many domains. The fact that even a single sword, as a tool, takes on different significance depending on whose backing it is held under is rich in implications for reading the history of Japanese swords. Even so, because the outward form of sword-wearing continued to be formally maintained as a samurai status custom, domain-defecting rōshi were placed in the unstable position of "able to wear a sword, but without backing." While there were examples like Sakamoto Ryōma who made use of the freedom of their post-defection position to carry out their activities, many rōshi lived through the Bakumatsu era while confronting the instability of having lost their livelihood. The single sword they wore at their hip was, beyond being mere weaponry, an expression of the will to remain a samurai even after losing the backing of one's domain. For those wishing to understand the relationship between sword-wearing and status across a broader historical timeline, reading Sword Abolishment Edict (Haitōrei) (1876) — The Truth Behind the Sword Ban and Why the Japanese Sword Survived will deepen that understanding.
← Economic Policies of the Tanuma Okitsugu Era and the Sword Trade and Forging Industry — The Impact of Kabunakama Recognition and Monetary Reform on the Business Environment of Tōkō
NextMitokoromono (kozuka, kōgai, menuki) — Classification and Function of the Three-Piece Tōsōgu Set →
History & Eras
History & Eras
History & ErasHow to buy from Japan, sword laws by country, and how to read certification papers
Thinking about buying from Japan? →