New Arrivals — Browse our catalog for the latest authentic Japanese sword arrivals. Browse →
* Image is for illustrative purposes only.The sword market sees tens of thousands of swords in circulation, ranging from kotō made several centuries ago to works of the Meiji and Shōwa periods. Among them are craftsmen who distinguish the genuine from the false, determine the period with precision, and set appropriate prices. They work as appraisers, dealers, and togishi (polishers who polish swords with whetstones), and their discerning eye is cultivated through decades of training. This article explains the roles of specialists in the sword market and the practical learning path for developing the eye of an expert.
Several specialist professions exist in the sword market.
The core of a sword dealer's discerning eye lies in internalizing the "forms" of each school and each period. For example, swords of the Sōshū-den and those of the Bizen-den differ in the texture of the jigane, the manner in which the hamon rises, and the shape of the kissaki (point). The Sōshū-den is characterized by fine granular brilliance known as nie-deki, while the Bizen-den is characterized by a smooth hamon also called nioi-deki. Dealers commit hundreds of kotō to memory and train until they can intuitively recognize the "face" of each school.
Next in importance is the authentication of the mei (signature). The mei carved into the nakago is a vital element proving the identity of the tōkō (swordsmith), but a fraudulent practice known as gimei (false signature) also exists. Dealers must study the carving style of the mei of renowned tōkō and distinguish the minute differences between a genuine mei and a gimei. For example, when confronted with a mei reading "Bishū Osafune Morimitsu," they determine from the thickness of the strokes, the depth of the carving, and the idiosyncrasies of the brushwork whether it is a gimei added later or the authentic mei carved by the smith himself.
The distinction between "newly made swords" and kotō is also a matter of the utmost importance for a dealer. No matter how skillfully a newly made sword produced since the Shōwa period copies an old work, slight differences appear. The color of the jigane, the way the hamon breaks down after yaki-ire (quenching), and the state of oxidation of the nakago metal serve as indicators distinguishing kotō from newly made swords. After polishing, the traces of the forging and the yaki-ire (quenching) can sometimes be seen clearly, and these become material for judgment.
To become a fully competent judge in the sword world, one must understand the characteristics of the Gokaden (five traditions) — Yamato-den, Yamashiro-den, Bizen-den, Sōshū-den, and Mino-den — to the marrow.
Characteristics by period are equally important. Kotō of the Kamakura period are characterized by long blades, strong sori (curvature), and a round kissaki known as inokubi-kissaki. The Nanbokuchō period sees a transition to a narrower sakihaba (width at the point) with a naka-kissaki. Shintō of the Edo period come to present a neat, well-ordered shape and a clear, bright color in the jigane. Recognizing such period-specific "faces" is the dealer's first step.
The learning path a beginner should take in order to cultivate a discerning eye for swords is as follows.
1. Stage One: Acquiring Foundational Knowledge Begin by learning the names of the parts of a sword, the basic characteristics of the Gokaden (five traditions), and the period classifications (jōkotō, kotō, shintō, shinshintō). It is important to read foundational works such as "Basics of Sword Appreciation" and "Complete Guide to the Gokaden" and absorb the terminology and concepts.
2. Stage Two: Observing Actual Swords Regularly visit museums and open sword exhibitions and observe as many actual swords as possible with the naked eye, from kotō to shintō. The luster of the jigane, the manner in which the hamon rises, and the rust patterns — all of which are difficult to convey in photographs — become easier to understand through direct contact with actual swords. By comparing multiple swords from the same school side by side, the characteristic "habits" of the school become visible.
3. Stage Three: Studying Catalogues and Papers Read catalogues from national art museums and papers from sword research associations. In particular, catalogues that explain a tōkō's representative works in detail are the finest teaching materials for understanding the "face" of that tōkō. By comparing and contrasting multiple catalogues and noticing the minute differences in characteristics among different swords by the same tōkō, the precision of one's discerning eye improves.
4. Stage Four: Attending Markets and Auctions Actually visit sword markets and auctions and record the going prices of consigned swords, the dealers' assessments, and the final hammer prices. By recognizing the degree to which one's own judgment diverges from the market's judgment, a practical discerning eye is honed. At the same time, undocumented knowledge can also be acquired through conversations with dealers and other enthusiasts.
5. Stage Five: Experiencing Polishing Where possible, it is ideal to attend the polishing of a sword at a togishi's workshop and directly experience the changes in the sword before and after polishing. Through the process of polishing, one can understand how the beauty of a kotō and the characteristics of its period come to light.
Dealers and appraisers who are genuinely active in the market are well acquainted with the following practical tips.
The training of a discerning eye is an endless path. Even a first-rate dealer will newly learn the characteristics when a sword by a tōkō of a new period comes to light. The specialists who are active in the sword market are craftsmen who face swords for life, continuously honing their eye. Browsing many swords in online catalogues also serves as basic training for this discerning eye.
← Sword Culture of the Shōhō, Keian, Jōō, Meireki, Manji, and Enpō Eras — The Eve of Enduring Peace, Shaken by the Great Fire and the Rōnin Problem
NextThe History and Types of Shinai — The Development of Sword Training and Sport Kendo →
Industry & Market
Industry & Market
Industry & MarketHow to buy from Japan, sword laws by country, and how to read certification papers
Thinking about buying from Japan? →