New Arrivals — Browse our catalog for the latest authentic Japanese sword arrivals. Browse →
* Image is for illustrative purposes only.The span from the first year of Hōreki (1751) to the end of Tenmei and the beginning of Kansei (around 1788–1789) was a turbulent transitional period passing through the reigns of the 9th shōgun Tokugawa Ieshige and the 10th shōgun Ieharu before moving to the 11th shōgun Ienari, and is known as the "Tanuma period" led by Senior Councillor Tanuma Okitsugu. Ieharu died in Tenmei 6 (1786), and from Tenmei 7 (1787) onward the era belongs to Ienari. This period, which sought to restore shogunate finances through commercial promotion and active fiscal policy, was a time when townspeople's culture reached its full bloom while subtle changes in attitudes toward swords also emerged within samurai society.
In contrast to the preceding Kyōhō Reforms (1716–1745), which had raised the banner of frugality and plain simplicity, the Tanuma period placed emphasis on stimulating economic activity, and interest in "swords to be seen" grew even within samurai society. The remarkable refinement of tōsōgu (tsuba, menuki, fuchi-kashira, kozuka) during this period was not unrelated to this historical backdrop.
Tanuma Okitsugu was born into a hatamoto family of originally modest stipend, yet achieved an extraordinary rise through service as a close attendant to the shōgun. He is also known for taking approaches that set him apart from the conventional agrarian-based fiscal management, such as officially recognizing trade guilds (kabunakama) and collecting commercial taxes from commercial activities. This notion of "harnessing the power of commerce" is thought to have influenced the valuation of goods within samurai society—especially swords and tōsōgu—preparing fertile ground in which not only utility but also design quality and rarity were prized.
The Gotō family (Gotōke), which had stood at the pinnacle of tōsōgu from the Muromachi period through the early Edo period, retained its privileged position as official metalworkers to the shogunate, yet during the Hōreki and Tenmei periods it was being relativized by the rise of independent individual metalworkers.
Even after the death of the Nara metalworker Tsuchiya Yasuchika (1670–1744), his disciples remained active in Edo and Osaka, producing works that added original designs to traditional casting and engraving techniques. In particular, the Higo metalwork (Kumamoto) school reached its peak during this period, establishing a distinctive aesthetic of applying simple openwork and modest gold and silver inlay to robust iron tsuba. This school comprises the following four groups.
This was also a period of diversification in tsuba materials, and works skillfully combining shakudō, shibuichi, gold, silver, and iron were prized among wealthy merchants and domain lords in Edo.
The styles of the Gotō family and the independent metalworkers differed as follows.
| School | Practitioners | Characteristics |
|---|---|---|
| Iebori | Gotō family | High-prestige designs primarily intended as presentations and gifts to the shōgun's house and domain lords |
| Machibori | Independent metalworkers who rose to prominence during the Hōreki and Tenmei periods | Freer and more naturalistic designs reflecting not only samurai but also the tastes of the wealthy merchant class |
This shift in center of gravity from iebori to machibori can be called the greatest change in tōsōgu history during the Hōreki and Tenmei periods.
In the forging technology of blades as well, the Hōreki and Tenmei periods were an important period of accumulation immediately preceding the shinshintō movement. While the publication of Suishinshi Masahide's landmark work Tōken Fukkōron came in Bunsei 9 (1826), its intellectual seeds lie in the experimental endeavors of tōkō during the Hōreki and Tenmei periods.
Many tōkō of this period were inheriting the conventions of the shintō era—a system in which tōkō from Sagami and Settsu produced work based in Edo and Osaka—while beginning to seek a return to the techniques of the older kotō. The mood of "kotō revival" drew on the currents of cultural asceticism and revivalism that had grown during the Kyōhō Reform period, and was shared among intellectuals and samurai of the Tenmei era.
The challenge that tōkō of the time faced was the limitation that the blade-making techniques established in the shintō era alone could not fully reproduce the beauty of jigane and the richly varied expression of hamon seen in the celebrated swords of the Kamakura and Nanbokuchō periods. For this reason, it is recorded that some tōkō returned even to such fundamental matters as the selection of iron raw materials and the tanren process, repeatedly experimenting in their efforts to approach the style of kotō. The accumulation of these painstaking explorations prepared the way for the shinshintō movement led by the next generation's Suishinshi Masahide and others.
As the mid-Edo period arrived, swords largely lost their meaning as instruments of actual combat, and their aspect as ceremonial implements signifying samurai identity came to the fore. This was also the period when the etiquette of wearing swords, handling swords at audiences, and the formalities surrounding the presentation and receipt of swords were refined.
Particularly noteworthy is the establishment and entrenchment of the practice known as denchūzashi. When attending Edo Castle, the carrying of long swords was prohibited, and only wakizashi below a specified length were permitted. This restriction gave rise to a specific form of tantō culture known as denchūzashi, accelerating the advanced artistic development of tōsōgu.
The ritual exchange of swords as gifts was also one of the fields that saw increasing refinement during this period. It was customary to present swords and tōsōgu on various occasions—auspicious events, funerals, or the expression of loyalty within lord-retainer relationships—and selecting appropriate koshirae and tōsōgu according to the recipient's rank was required as a mark of samurai cultivation. The spread of this gift-giving culture is also thought to have been one factor underpinning the demand for tōsōgu not merely as functional items but as works of art.
The great Tenmei Famine that began in Tenmei 3 (1783) brought enormous damage centered on the Tōhoku region and dealt a serious blow to shogunate finances. This economic blow also reached the sword industry, with orders for expensive custom swords declining and a certain brake being applied to the elaboration of tōsōgu.
The damage of this famine is said to have been compounded by the combination of ashfall from the great eruption of Mount Asama and crop failures from cold weather centered on the Tōhoku region, bringing social unrest to various parts of the country that went beyond mere fiscal problems.
Paradoxically, however, this economic hardship also contributed to the technical deepening of tōkō skills. The reduction in orders gave tōkō the leeway to devote time to "experimental works for honing technique" rather than "mass-produced items that would sell," deepening the technical exploration that would connect to the later shinshintō revival movement.
The Hōreki and Tenmei periods tend to be overlooked in sword history precisely because they lack spectacular political events or major foreign wars, but as the era in which the transition of swords from practical instruments to art objects and ceremonial implements was completed, they represent an indispensable period in understanding Japanese sword culture.
Today, when appreciating or collecting swords and tōsōgu made during the Hōreki and Tenmei periods, several perspectives serve as guides. First, for tōsōgu such as tsuba and menuki, the distinction between the iebori and machibori traditions described above provides a fundamental starting point for reading design and technique. Comparing works from the perspective of whether the design emphasizes the prestige directed at the shōgun's or domain lords' households, or whether it reflects the naturalistic tastes of the merchant class, makes it easier to grasp the individuality of each piece.
Second, since this era falls in a transitional period from shintō to shinshintō, differences in the tendencies of jigane and hamon may sometimes be observed between the mei of tōkō who attempted a return to kotō techniques and those of tōkō who strongly retained the style established since the shintō era. Where, as with the four schools of Higo metalwork, the tendency of designs favored by each school is known, this too serves as a clue to reading the background of a piece.
In either case, the final judgment on period, maker, and tradition is best confirmed through appraisal by NBTHK (Society for the Preservation of Japanese Art Swords). In particular, for mumei tōsōgu and koshirae that may have been altered in later periods, the evaluation indicated in a kanteisho from a specialist institution becomes an important basis for understanding the provenance and value of a piece.
← Expert Guide to Kōgai: From Heian Origins to the Four Schools of Higo Metalwork, Kōgai as an Entry Point for Tōsōgu Collecting
NextFerrite, Pearlite, Martensite: An Introduction to Steel Microstructure for Understanding Nihontō →
History & Eras
History & Eras
History & ErasHow to buy from Japan, sword laws by country, and how to read certification papers
Thinking about buying from Japan? →